Contact Us




Change Locale

Could there still be a place for tape?

From the experts | Posted on February 14, 2012 by Ferrol Macon

Often, new technologies bury old ones – think of the demise of the horse and buggy or the record player. But sometimes, established technologies have a funny way of flailing for a bit then finding a new equilibrium. In-theater movie going, for instance, didn’t die when at-home devices became popular – they both simply learned to coexist in an expanded marketplace to the benefit and joy of consumers who now had more freedom than before.

Here’s another great example: For years now, ever since the advent of the disk, pundits have predicted the apocalyptic demise of tape backup – derisively calling it “end-of-life” technology.

But it just hasn’t happened. Tape is still here, firmly entrenched in the overwhelming majority (82%) of onsite backups. Or to borrow from Mark Twain, “the reports of physical tape’s death have been greatly exaggerated.”

In fact, tape solutions continue to play a huge role for backup, recovery, long-term data retention and data protection in most organizations, particularly small and medium sized businesses.


For one, disk solutions are still more than 15 times more costly than tape. Disk technology also uses nearly 250 times more energy, meaning the energy costs alone to run disks can cost more than the entire cost of tape, which for its part still costs only about 3 cents a gigabyte. And an examination of acquisition costs and total cost of ownership of tape versus disk-based architectures over a five-year timeframe shows that tape easily wins on both fronts.

Secondly and related to the bottom line cost issue is the reality that many enterprises – and particular SMBs – simply can’t afford to wait to recover huge technology investments over an extended period of time. And they understand that there’s no point
spending more than they need (or have) on pricey disks for storing data they’ll rarely, and hopefully never have to access again.

Thirdly, a strong case can be made for tape over disk when it comes to offline and offsite data protection. If a network goes down or a hurricane or earthquake takes out your data center, tape provides a physical archived record of your data away from the mayhem.

Finally, while tape once had a well-deserved reputation for being unreliable and difficult to use, today’s tape drives and LTO technology are highly reliable and incredibly simple to manage.

In the final analysis – like movie versus home theaters – there will continue to be a role to play for both tape and disk backup technologies, particularly for cost-conscious enterprises. Blending the two allows businesses to achieve the performance they need – for instance, the need to access high availability data – while still keeping a handle on strained budgets. And those strained budgets may be a big reason why a recent Fleishman-Hillard survey revealed that 61% of disk-only users still planned to start using this so-called “end-of-life” tape technology.

If Mark Twain understood what the heck data storage was, he’d be smiling right now.

Related Post: On demand scalability, simpler management and more.

Related Posts

Protect Your Infrastructure from Maintenance Sprawl Simplicity is among the principal advantages of implementing a virtual infrastructure, but few talk about the complexity that can come with it. Often, companies are far down t...
Isn’t It Time You Hopped on the Virtualization Bandwagon? – UPDATED Editor's note: our virtualization expert Stephen Akuffo weighs in on the Virtual Space Race Study blog series - see his notes below. You’ve probably researched how virt...
Healing the woes of migrating user profiles The last layer of abstraction: Virtualizing it is easier than you think.  If you’ve been following this series of posts – here and here  – you’ve probably already gotten a ...

Related Articles

  An Interview with Softchoice’s SVP of IT, Jeff Reis When Canada’s most valuable public company Shopify announced it was going “digital by default,” it was a clear a sign that the brick-and-mortar office era was forever changed. “We cannot go back to the way things were. This isn’t a choice. This is the future,” […]

Each year, Softchoice hosts the Innovation Executive Forum, meeting with hundreds of CIOs and senior IT leaders at exclusive events across North America. We capture the best insights in an annual report to share what our IEF members have on their minds and what they’ve learned. Before we get into this year’s report, we wanted […]

The unanticipated changes forced by the global health crisis haven’t been easy for any organization. As an initial response to the situation, many IT leaders and executives had to shift their workforce to all-remote work, whether they were ready or not. Now, many are looking ahead to new challenges as their organizations work to stabilize […]